Similarities between max and liesel in the book thief

Anne franks friend lies appears to her in a dream wearing rags and sad. The book thief by markus zusak movie clip my preference the reasons for the movie change theme. After tragedy strikes her family, liesel is adopted by kindhearted workingclass painter hans hubermann geoffrey rush and his strict but loving wife rose emily watson. They both have nightmares about their pasts, and they both see hans hubermann and his accordion as a source of safety. Later, liesels descriptions of the weather outside to max also help to establish a bond between them. While it both deals with the holocaust, it was the basis of humanity in both stories that really got to me. In the book thief, words have the power to both destroy and save lives. I have only read one other book which is from the perspective of death, and that book is called keturah and lord death by martine leavitt. In the movie the hand painted mein kampf gets thrown into the river. While reading the beginning chapters of the book thief, i noticed that there were some very definite differences between liesels foster parents rosa and hans hubermann. Write notes about two possible topics for your essay from those suggested below power of language one option. What does max believe are the two most pitiful words he can say. In the movie max dreams of becoming a boxer and fighting hitler. Rudy sees maxs name written on one of liesels books and discovers the secret of max while he is still in the basement.

Max and liesel have so many similarities, you could guess they were related. In the next couple slides we will answer the questions how does max s life give liesel purpose. The story, narrated by death himself, follows a young girl as she arrives in a small town in germany to live with her new foster parents as ww2 looms. Differences between the book thief book vs movie page 1. Summary max moves to the basement and continues to feel guilty for leaving his family and for putting hans, rosa, and liesel in danger. In the movie of the book thief, she walks silently away. Maxs book, the word shaker, describes how liesels words give him strength and have the ability to cut down forests of hate. His father saved hanss life during world war i, and later hans tries to save maxs life, which puts the hubermanns lives in great jeopardy. Another way they are similar is they are close to the same age, liesel being only 8 months younger than rudy. He feels deeply guilty for leaving his family to save himself, an act he sees as a choice rather than a necessity to survive.

Therefore, the novel the book thief develops the relationship between liesel meminger and her neighbours more than the film the book thief thereby minimizing the theme. The book thief books or movies similar to the book thief. In the book, the whistler gets thrown into the river when rudy finds out about max. They finally go down, and hans sees that max is freezing and emaciated. The greatest gift max gives liesel in the novel is words in. They both have nightmares about their pasts, and they both see hans hubermann and his. Well look at how she grows and changes between 1939 and 1943 by looking at what each of the books mean to her. I read the book thief and am wondering what are some good compare and contrast points when looking at max and liesel. The stranger turns out to be max vandenburg, a jewish man with a. Anne frank and max vandenberg are jews who yearn to go outside for just a few seconds. What are some of the similarities between liesel and max. Examine how characters in the novel for example, liesel, max, ilsa hermann, hitler, rosa andor hans use words to destroy and to save. When we first meet max, he is in a train coming to molching, with a notecard with hans hermans information, who apparently knew maxs father in the war. From the book to the movie, there have been many changes in characters too.

Despite just reading the first half of the book thief, similarities between the two have already been made evident to me. I think that the reason that the directors and producers made changes to the novel is because first. Liesel not only cares about specific people in her life such as hans, rudy, and max, she cares about justice in general, and feels frustrated and angry at the. Compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max vandenburg. Liesel and max have both lost families, they have both gained new parents in the character of hans and rosa, they each suffer from survivors guilt, they both have nightmares, and they both love to read.

One night hans wants to start up their reading practice of the shoulder shrug again, but liesel is nervous about going into the basement. Besides from some obvious differences as gender, nationalities, and age, they also have very different minds. Although liesel is nervous meeting max at first, they quickly become good friends. He was staying place to place or more, storage unit to basements without a family, without any hope really. Comparative essay the book thief 1722 words bartleby. If its the rebellious aspect of the book thief that drew you in, then to kill a mockingbird was made for you. For max, simply surviving is an act of resistance against hitler. Through all, max and liesel become true friends, helping each other to survive their losses. Max vandenburg is the jewish man who hides in the hubermanns basement. Liesel and max the friendship that develops between liesel and max is touching, heartwrenching, and extremely powerful. Perhaps the reason that these two characters gravitate towards each other is because of their incredible similarities. Get an answer for in the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max. Although one was a jewish fist fighter and one was a german book thief, max and liesel soon saw that they had things in common.

Comparecontrast liesel meminger and max vandenburg max vandenburg was a jew in hiding in the 1940s. In a beautiful and ironic gesture, max paints the pages of a copy of mein kampf so that he can write a story and paint pictures for liesela gift of a book, a most meaningful choice. Lets discuss how liesel and maxs experiences are really. Social discrimination towards the main characters, a theme of. In the next couple slides we will answer the questions how does maxs life give liesel purpose. The relationship between max and liesel is a great marvel in markus zusaks, the book thief, and is a huge turning point in the book as well. The friendship between liesel and max in the last 100 pages that we have read, i must say that the friendship between max and liesel is one of the more important parts of the book.

During the period of time that he hid in the hubermanns home, max and liesel became friends. Another major difference between the two mediums is that, in the book, liesels best. The book thief is a story narrated by a compassionate death who tells us about liesel, a girl growing up in germany during world war ii. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of the book thief and what it means. In the film, it was the blank book max had given liesel.

The lives of liesel and max are similar in that both have been traumatized by loss by the time they meet. He also feels ashamed of the burden he places on the hubermanns since he knows hes putting them in serious danger by being in their home. What does maxs mother hand him before he escapes with walter. The characters liesel meminger and rudy stiener are very similar in many ways. These are just a few of the differences between the book and movie versions of the book thief. Unfortunately max must hide in their basement cellar. Each book depicts the jews at the concentrations camps the same. In the movie, though, max is reading a newspaper and dismally says that germany is winning the war.

Both have left their respective families and have been adopted by the hubermans. Did anyone else notice the stark similarities between these two. So, we think a good way to analyze liesels character. She steals books, learns to read, and finds comfort in words. According to death, liesels book, the book thief, is divided in this way as well. Theres the book, of course, and it was put out as a movie in 1959, 1980, and 2009 plus several made for tv moviesminiseries. Other similarities not yet noted are the characters of max and tom both being victims of the settings of the novels. Also they both suffer from survivors guilt they dont think that they should have lived and. Lets discuss how liesel and max s experiences are really.

The differences between the book thief book and the book. In the book thief liesel and rudy give bread to the jews and it describes them as staggering to walk and starving. The book thief cliffsnotes study guides book summaries. What threats does hans make to instill in liesel the importance of keeping max secret. In the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max. Book comparison the book thief and to kill a mockingbird. When max and liesel have a joyful reunion, its almost like the jewish fighter is punching hitler right in the face. One way they are similar is because they both enjoy some of the same activities, like soccer and stealing.

Rudy finds out about max after he has left the basement. The similarities and differences of max and liesel the lark. However, in the movie, liesel actually goes as far as to tell rudy about hiding max. The story of book thief is about liesel meminger and is told by the death, who is haunted by humans. If you are trying to match the book thiefs idea of hiding a jew in wartime germany, perhapsthe diary of a young girl in one of its many incarnations will work for you. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. After hans is seen giving some bread to a jew, they are both whipped by a. Study 55 terms the book thief study guide flashcards. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.

How max plays an important role in liesels life, essays. The hubermanns decide that max will sleep upstairs and then return to the basement during the day, and they start to form a routine. Max vandenburg and liesel have a lot of similarities in there lifes they both have nightmares about something horrible that happened to them and they still cant heal from that experience. The book thief book vs film with a book as beloved as markus zusaks the book thief, an adaptation was always going to be a challenge. A summary of part four in markus zusaks the book thief. If it had been the whistler, the hubermanns secret would have been kept long after max safely escaped the basement. When liesel moved to 33 himmelstreet rudy became her next door neighbour. A tremendous book such as the book thief always leaves you wanting more and to kill a mockingbird is the perfect solution. And while it may seem like i thought the movie was complete rubbish, that is. Liesel, in the act of watching, was already noticing the similarities between this stranger and herself. The book that was thrown into the river in the novel, was a book liesel had stolen to read to max.

Those losses have made them wary, but they understand that they cannot survive on their own. In the book thief how is the relationship between liesel. After reading and finishing night, i found numerous of similarities between that book and the book thief. No matter the situations and surroundings, one can always find love and happiness. The novel the book thief develops the relationship between hans hubermann and liesel meminger more than the film the book thief therefore minimizing the theme. In the book of the book thief, liesel meminger learns through various ways that the nazi party is inimical. We will compare and contrast liesel and max, and we will explain the significence of the story the standover man you could argue. Social discrimination and judgment are more powerful than ever, but rebelliousness is too. Max vandenburg is a young jewish man who changes the hubermanns lives. Her soul, like her papas, sat up when death came for her, and as she went she thought of her three children, her grandchildren, her husband, and the many loved ones from her past, especially. He states that the book thief died only yesterday, that she lived a long life in a place far away from munich and himmel street in a suburb of sydney.

They also share a history of fistfighting and a respect for words. Liesel gets angry and throws a book at ilsa when she is told she wont be delivering the laundry anymore. A comparison between ambition present in the novels in comparing shakespeares macbeth and zusaks book thief, though the books deal with different time eras, characters and even language styles, there are some striking similarities between the themes in both. Bonding over nightmares, both the feeling of guilt, both found comfort in hans home etc. They both love to read and write, they are both very curious people, and they have what sophie already pointed out. I like how you wrote about their similarities and their differences. Book thief movie from my local library to compare the two mediums. On what pretext does rosa come to the school to tell liesel max has awakened. In many ways max and liesel are similar they both have.

Get an answer for in the book thief how is the relationship between liesel and rudy like family, lovers, strangers, and enemies. In the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of. Death is the sympathetic narrator of liesels story. And while it may seem like i thought the movie was complete rubbish, that is really only in comparison to the original text. Max, like liesel, comes to the story fresh from experiencing great loss. Besides the common narrator, death in both novels is portrayed as someonesomething that is agreeable, but not necessarily nice. What similarities between herself and max does liesel recognize right away. In my opinion, i believe that they are so different that they act as foil characters to each other. For liesels 12th birthday, rosa and hans give her a book, the mud men. Also, there is a scene when rudy goes back for liesels shoes that were left at the mayors house when she was stealing from ilsas library. Differences between the book thief book vs movie page 2. Max writes books for liesel about all that she has done for him and about how her words and her tears are able to save him and give him strength.